On the night of March 2, 1998, 20-year-old Suzanne boarded a city bull in Albany, New York and headed back to her college campus. Another student saw her get off the bus at a place that was just a short walk to Suzy’s dorm. But she never made it home, and she was never seen again. Evidence suggests she may have been the first victim of serial killer Israel Keyes, but we’ll probably never know for sure. So what happened? Where. The Hell. Is Suzy?

LOOKING FOR MORE PATRICK AND ELLYN? JOIN OUR PATREON! At the $5 level you get 3 FULL BONUS EPISODES PER MONTH! Right now there are over 15 full bonus episode to download and binge right this second! AND YOU GET TO PLAY OUR MONTHLY TRUE CRIME TRIVIA! We do it on Zoom, we all get to hang out, and you can win cool prizes!!! Plus there are ad-free versions of our entire catalog of episodes! CLICK HERE TO JOIN!

Get the future of podcasts.