What are your interests?
Select categories to help us recommend content for you.
Let's Go!
Close queue History
Play full episodes to fill your queue.
Fathom beta logo
   
I Think Not!

I Think Not!

222 Episodes • By I Think Not! • audioboom.com/channels/5020371-i...
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Elly ...more
Society & Culture True Crime
I Think Not!
I Think Not!
@obsessedwith:disappeared
mute button
196: Got to Be the Black Market Maestro (I (Almost) Got Away With It)
After a jury acquits Kylen for attempted murder, he ... more
Apr 24 2024 1h 10m
Close to Freedom, Unexpected Encounter
Chapter 1 4 mins
Podcasters Discuss Headphones and Tour
Chapter 2 9 mins
Crime Spree and Sunscreen
Chapter 3 2 mins
Coke, Weed, and Suspicion
Chapter 4 13 mins
Cougar Dating Gone Wrong
Chapter 5 14 mins
The Fence
Chapter 6 13 mins
Silk Pillowcases and Phone Theft
Chapter 7 9 mins
Kylan Padgett's Crime Spree
Chapter 8 2 mins
Podcast Announcement and Banter
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
195: Got to Escape with One Leg (I (Almost) Got Away With It)
Walter Rhodes agrees to testify against others in ex... more
Apr 17 2024 1h 14m
Roadside Encounter With Handsome Constable
Chapter 1 3 mins
Virginia Community Colleges and Podcast Patreon
Chapter 2 10 mins
Live Tour Announcement and Crime Story
Chapter 3 8 mins
Rapid Escalation of Crime
Chapter 4 5 mins
Police Helicopter Pursuit and Legal Drama
Chapter 5 4 mins
Escape From Prison With One Leg
Chapter 6 11 mins
Escape Attempt at a Southern Prison
Chapter 7 12 mins
Love, Redemption, and Betrayal
Chapter 8 3 mins
Navigating Social Battery and Finding Truth
Chapter 9 13 mins
Wrongful Convictions and Redemption
Chapter 10 1 min
Making Friends and Having Fun
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
Rabia and Ellyn Solve the Case with Hilarie Burton Morgan (Zodiac)
Hi Down Bitches! In case you missed it, we wanted to... more
Apr 12 2024 1h 41m
Discussion of Zodiac Killer Suspects
Chapter 1 5 mins
Celebrity True Crime Podcast Interview
Chapter 2 3 mins
Exciting Conversation With Hillary Burton
Chapter 3 9 mins
Podcast Hosts Chat About Life
Chapter 4 4 mins
Parenting Girls and True Crime Passion
Chapter 5 4 mins
The Phenomenon of Female Fear
Chapter 6 14 mins
Uncovering the Mystery of Zodiac Killer
Chapter 7 7 mins
Unsolved Murder Case and Serial Killer
Chapter 8 11 mins
Uncovering Possible Zodiac Killer Suspect
Chapter 9 10 mins
Uncovering Connections in Zodiac Killings
Chapter 10 3 mins
Uncovering the Zodiac Killer Profile
Chapter 11 5 mins
Speculating on Zodiac Suspects
Chapter 12 5 mins
The Zodiac Killer
Chapter 13 13 mins
Unsolved Crime Investigation Discussion
Chapter 14 20 sec
Instagram Handles and Goodbyes
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
194: Got to Pose as a War Vet (I (Almost) Got Away With It)
A criminal is wanted in four states for posing as a ... more
Apr 10 2024 1h 17m
Online Chat Leads to Mistaken Identity
Chapter 1 2 mins
Late Night Podcast Banter
Chapter 2 6 mins
Meeting Rick and Patreon Updates
Chapter 3 14 mins
Teenage Rebellion and Unexpected Consequences
Chapter 4 5 mins
Uniforms and Dating
Chapter 5 12 mins
The Great Debit Card Heist
Chapter 6 12 mins
The Car Dealership Con
Chapter 7 12 mins
The Con Artist's Downfall
Chapter 8 9 mins
Rise and Fall of Jared Durr
Chapter 9 1 min
Podcast Tour Updates and Bloopers
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
193: Got to Escape Through a Toilet (I (Almost) Got Away With It)
A pair of friends and criminals escape from prison i... more
Apr 3 2024 52m
Fugitives on the Run and Jokes
Chapter 1 4 mins
True Crime Podcast
Chapter 2 5 mins
The Harley Davidson Robbery and Arrest
Chapter 3 7 mins
Escape Attempt at Putnam County Jail
Chapter 4 12 mins
Escape From a Florida Jail
Chapter 5 11 mins
The Grandma Helen Murder Case
Chapter 6 9 mins
Police Chase and Capture Fugitives
Chapter 7 1 min
I Think Not Podcast Tour Announcement
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
192: Allridges (Killer Siblings)
After three ruthless murders and a months-long spree... more
Mar 27 2024 1h 12m
Armed Robbery Mix-Up
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
191: Merricks (Killer Siblings)
A double homicide in a small Ohio town leads police ... more
Mar 20 2024 1h 13m
Indictment and Plea Deals
Chapter 1 6 mins
Podcast Recap
Chapter 2 11 mins
Small Town Crime Investigation
Chapter 3 12 mins
Tragedy, Surveillance, and Neighborly Connections
Chapter 4 6 mins
Trust and Suspicion in Relationships
Chapter 5 11 mins
Family Tensions and Murder Investigation
Chapter 6 13 mins
Detectives Interrogate Murder Suspects
Chapter 7 11 mins
Double Murder and Sentencing Details
Chapter 8 1 min
Podcast Hosts Express Love and Updates
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
190: Engels (Killer Siblings)
When the body of a young woman is found in a burnt-o... more
Mar 13 2024 1h 4m
Details of Cooperation in Criminal Investigation
Chapter 1 11 mins
Morning Podcast Banter
Chapter 2 6 mins
Billboard #1 Song & Missing Person
Chapter 3 11 mins
The Tale of Zamara and William
Chapter 4 9 mins
Mysterious Homicide Investigation in the 80s
Chapter 5 5 mins
Suspicious Circumstances Surrounding ZMRA's Death
Chapter 6 4 mins
Investigation Into Pee Wee's Involvement
Chapter 7 5 mins
The Hitman and the Boss
Chapter 8 9 mins
The Engle Brothers
Chapter 9 1 min
Podcast Membership Benefits and Community
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
189: Kimbles (Killer Siblings)
A peaceful town is rocked by the murder of the young... more
Mar 6 2024 1h 8m
Small Town Gossip in North Carolina
Chapter 1 13 mins
True Crime Podcast and Live Shows
Chapter 2 14 mins
1995 True Crime House Fire
Chapter 3 5 mins
The Murder of Patricia Kimball
Chapter 4 6 mins
Family Dynamics and Tragic Events
Chapter 5 9 mins
Investigation of Patricia Kimball's Murder
Chapter 6 10 mins
The Kimball Brothers' Potential Involvement
Chapter 7 7 mins
Killer Siblings
Chapter 8 1 min
Podcast Social Media and Patreon Updates
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
188: Stranger Danger ft. Reality Gays with Mattie and Poodle (Phrogging)
After Heidi Lane moves to the big city, her underwea... more
Feb 28 2024 1h 31m
Unsolved Theft and Home Invasion
Chapter 1 10 mins
Chatty Podcast Recap With Gays
Chapter 2 11 mins
Parental Concerns and Ultrasounds
Chapter 3 9 mins
Underwear Mystery Unraveled With Humor
Chapter 4 12 mins
The Phone Goes Missing
Chapter 5 10 mins
Attic Stalker Exposed
Chapter 6 11 mins
Bucktown Rooftop Burglary Suspended Sentence
Chapter 7 4 mins
Terrifying Hooded Figure Caught on Camera
Chapter 8 6 mins
Neighborly Drama and Security Scare
Chapter 9 11 mins
Bucktown Creeper Incident and Investigation
Chapter 10 4 mins
Love After Lockup and Theater Talk
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
187: For the Love of Drama (Death by Fame)
Adea Shabani crossed oceans to pursue her Hollywood ... more
Feb 21 2024 59m
Phone Data Leads to Discovery
Chapter 1 9 mins
True Crime Podcast Tour Announcement
Chapter 2 9 mins
Missing Actress in Hollywood Investigation
Chapter 3 7 mins
Mystery Surrounding Adea's Disappearance
Chapter 4 12 mins
The Deceptive Double Life of Chris
Chapter 5 8 mins
Investigation Into Disappearance of Adea
Chapter 6 9 mins
Complex Homicide Case and Investigation
Chapter 7 1 min
Death by Fame Farewell Episode
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
186: Behind the Screen (Death by Fame)
Singer Christina Grimmie went from internet sensatio... more
Feb 14 2024 1h 14m
Devastating Deal Falls Through
Chapter 1 4 mins
Shopify, Broadway Self-Tapes, and Birthday Musings
Chapter 2 10 mins
Discussion of Sponsor and Christina Grimmie
Chapter 3 8 mins
Social Media's Impact on Artists' Connection
Chapter 4 13 mins
YouTube Fame and Music Industry Dreams
Chapter 5 8 mins
Dreaming Big and Finding Your Worth
Chapter 6 8 mins
Tragedy Strikes at Christina Grimmie Concert
Chapter 7 11 mins
Tragic Shooting and Investigation
Chapter 8 7 mins
Gun Control and the Tragic Impact
Chapter 9 33 sec
The Power of Negative Comments
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
185: Man of Anarchy (Death by Fame)
Johnny Lewis has everything any 28-year-old actor co... more
Feb 7 2024 1h 6m
Straightforward and Unfiltered Conversations
Chapter 1 9 mins
Choice, Discussion, and Fame' Simplify This Chapter Title Into 6 Words or Less
Chapter 2 4 mins
Child Actor's Journey in Hollywood
Chapter 3 9 mins
Hollywood Relationships
Chapter 4 10 mins
Johnny Quits Hit TV Show
Chapter 5 6 mins
Johnny's Motorcycle Accident and Mental Decline
Chapter 6 10 mins
Tragic Story of Johnny Angel Wendell
Chapter 7 14 mins
Murder and Speculation
Chapter 8 2 mins
Promotion of Harry's Men's Grooming Company
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
184: Celebrity Sexpert (Death by Fame)
Sex therapist Amie Harwick has the beauty and brains... more
Jan 31 2024 1h 1m
Controversy Surrounding Amy's Murder Trial
Chapter 1 9 mins
Hollywood, Podcasts, and Exclusive Content
Chapter 2 10 mins
Amy Harwick
Chapter 3 6 mins
Relationship Drama and Career Success
Chapter 4 6 mins
Amy's Journey as a Sex Therapist
Chapter 5 8 mins
Amy Harwick's Death and Relationship
Chapter 6 8 mins
Amy's Ex's Harassment and Online Harassment
Chapter 7 9 mins
Amy Harwick's Murder and Trial
Chapter 8 1 min
VIP Q&A and Meet & Greet
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
183: Snapped S25E3
When a revered fire lieutenant is gunned down in his... more
Jan 24 2024 1h 9m
Chad's Alibi and Cell Phone Investigation
Chapter 1 8 mins
Personal Relationships and Last Episode
Chapter 2 8 mins
William L Walker
Chapter 3 8 mins
The Slow-Building Relationship and Tragic Shooting
Chapter 4 7 mins
Lt. William Walker Murder Investigation
Chapter 5 5 mins
Mysterious Murder
Chapter 6 13 mins
Murder Investigation and Family Dynamics
Chapter 7 15 mins
Conspiracy to Murder
Chapter 8 1 min
Patreon Membership and Community Love
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
182: Snapped S25E2 ft. Kristin and Brandi from Let’s Go to Court
The disappearance of an Arkansas couple leads to a m... more
Jan 17 2024 1h 16m
Ted's Truck and Missing People
Chapter 1 4 mins
Podcasters Discuss Inappropriate Stories
Chapter 2 5 mins
Long-Lasting Friendship and Random Discussions
Chapter 3 10 mins
Missing Persons Case in the Ozarks
Chapter 4 14 mins
Finding Love, Avoiding a Ho Phase
Chapter 5 5 mins
Unsettling Discovery in Allred, Arkansas
Chapter 6 5 mins
Ted's Disappearance and Suspicious Signs
Chapter 7 10 mins
Investigation and Personal Stories
Chapter 8 5 mins
Armed Standoff and Escapes in Darkness
Chapter 9 14 mins
Disturbing Murder Plan Details
Chapter 10 31 sec
Search and Medication Procedure Discussion
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
181: Georgia Watson (Snapped)
When a man is ambushed by a firestorm of bullets out... more
Jan 10 2024 1h
Greeley Detectives and Dubuque Investigation
Chapter 1 11 mins
Podcast and Mushroom Retreat Plans
Chapter 2 12 mins
911 Call Leads to Shooting Incident
Chapter 3 9 mins
Investigation Into a Violent Murder
Chapter 4 8 mins
Intriguing Connections and Suspicious Individuals
Chapter 5 11 mins
Investigation and Arrest of Cecil & Justin
Chapter 6 6 mins
Georgia and Cecil's Murder Conspiracy Trial
Chapter 7 48 sec
Promotion of Podcast and Patreon
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
180: Bonus From Patreon - Can’t Stop Destiny (Love After Lockup)
As part of our dark week, we have a special surprise... more
Jan 3 2024 1h 13m
Surprising Strip Club Plan for Husband
Chapter 1 13 mins
Love After Lockup
Chapter 2 3 mins
Lindsay's Release and Ex-Boyfriend's Petty Actions
Chapter 3 2 mins
Lindsay's New Boyfriend and Jealousy
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
178: From Patreon - The Secrets of Bissonnet Street: from Disappeared (S11E4)
This episode originally aired on Patreon on 11.16.23... more
Dec 27 2023 45m
Investigator Searches for Missing Person in Atlanta
Chapter 1 6 mins
Name Change and Serious Recap Discussion
Chapter 2 5 mins
Social Media and Child Safety Concerns
Chapter 3 9 mins
Houston Police Corruption and Human Trafficking
Chapter 4 6 mins
Find Missing Teen, Address Police Inaction
Chapter 5 14 mins
The Search for Missing Kristen
Chapter 6 1 min
Discussing Corruption and a Personal Story
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
179: Special Interview with Kristen Galvan’s Mother, Robyn Cory
We sit down and talk with Robyn Cory, Mama Robyn, Kr... more
Dec 27 2023 36m
Detective's Lack of Empathy and Disrespect
Chapter 1 3 mins
Exclusive Conversation With Kristen Galvan's Mother
Chapter 2 12 mins
Misrepresentation and Pain
Chapter 3 9 mins
Human Trafficking Corruption and Failure
Chapter 4 5 mins
Child Trafficking in Texas and Advocacy
Chapter 5 5 mins
Supporting Missing Families, Fighting Child Trafficking
Chapter 6 1 min
Fitness Program for Beginners by Lacey Green
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
177: Pandora Zan (Snapped)
After a home invasion in Ohio leaves a corrections o... more
Dec 20 2023 59m
The Brady Bunch and Ohio's Scarecrow
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
176: My Beloved Smother (True Nightmares)
After trick or treating with his family on Halloween... more
Dec 13 2023 1h 4m
Creepy Show and Air Traffic Controller
Chapter 1 9 mins
Locking Doors and True Crime Podcast
Chapter 2 9 mins
Trick-or-Treating Horror
Chapter 3 12 mins
Child Murder and Insurance Fraud
Chapter 4 10 mins
Boy-Mom Culture and Mysterious Disappearance
Chapter 5 6 mins
Elizabeth Duncan's Murder Plot and Arrest
Chapter 6 6 mins
Dark Crimes and Lies in Florida
Chapter 7 9 mins
A Fake Death and Mysterious Singer
Chapter 8 47 sec
Love and Jokes With Joey + Ellen
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
175: Friends Like These (True Nightmares)
Nancy Bowen doesn't get to say goodbye to her husban... more
Dec 6 2023 52m
Mysterious Death
Chapter 1 14 mins
Thanksgiving Traditions and True Crime Recap
Chapter 2 7 mins
Holiday Gift Shop and Murder Mystery
Chapter 3 12 mins
Factory Workers Fall Ill
Chapter 4 6 mins
The Deadly Diary
Chapter 5 10 mins
The Mysterious Deaths of Mike Malloy
Chapter 6 1 min
Promotion and Recommendations for Podcast
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
Not AI Processed
Previews and search are not yet available for this episode.

Autoplay will start you at the beginning of the episode.
stars icon No captions Available
174: Thoughts and New Information on the Daniel Robinson Case from his Father, David
Ellyn and Joey sit down and discuss the Daniel Robin... more
Nov 29 2023 56m
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full
mute button
173: Larger Than Death (True Nightmares)
Police investigate the real secret of Crime Scene Li... more
Nov 22 2023 1h 1m
Handwriting Links Joseph Meiling to Crime
Like
Clip
Share
Transcript
More
Play Full